Medical decision-making

7:35 PM

Author | Andrea Knittel

I know the title sounds approximately as riveting as not at all, but I've been thinking a lot about it since I've started my ICU month. While I've been reflecting on the medical decisions I'm making, in the time I take to process everything I've seen, I've been focused more on those we expect the patients and families we care for to make. We call on them during their most dire hours and ask them to consider options they don't necessarily understand, to weigh risks and benefits that are hard to put into context, and to make calls that no one ever wants to have to make. And they do it. Not always with the calm and rational process that would be easiest for the physicians working for them, but more often than not with an incredible degree of grace and reflection mixed into the grief and frustration.

The conversations are almost always accompanied by a great deal of sighing, sobbing, and shouting, which can be disconcerting to those of us working to provide medical care. I think what made me most frustrated back when President Obama's plans to encourage the discussion of advanced directives turned into a death panel debacle, was the callousness of it with regard to the families of critically ill patients. How many of the individuals who were most loudly heard during that national discussion had been in the position of trying to determine the appropriate goals of care for a loved one at the end of life? I'd hazard a guess that there were very few. Anyone who has had to weigh these questions, particularly without the benefit of a signed document crafted by the patient him/herself charging the course ahead, would think twice about protesting a more considered approach.

With or without a mandate from the government, however, I increasingly believe that physicians and other healthcare providers have a serious obligation to discuss end of life care with all of their patients. A few questions about code status when a person is hospitalized (i.e., whether or not an individual would want chest compressions, shocks to the heart, or other measures to bring back a patient whose heart has stopped while in the hospital) are simply not enough. Although I have been impressed with the way many of my teachers and mentors have navigated these challenging situations with hospitalized patients and their loved ones, I can't help but wish that as a nation we could pause, reflect on what we want from our last weeks, days, and hours, and take a moment to write it down.

Looking for more resources on Advanced Directives and Living Wills? Check here for the UMHS Publication.

Media Contact Public Relations

Department of Communication at Michigan Medicine

[email protected]

734-764-2220

Stay Informed

Want top health & research news weekly? Sign up for Health Lab’s newsletters today!

Subscribe
Featured News & Stories two men together walking outside
Health Lab
Exercise can reduce your cancer risk and help prevent its return
A director of exercise and health behavior in oncology shares ways to help cancer survivors live longer and better lives by incorporating exercise and other physical activity into everyday routines.
sink brushing pink toothbrush
Health Lab
Fluoride Q&A: An expert breaks down how it helps kids, and its unique history in Michigan
Sarah Clark, M.P.H., from the Department of Pediatrics at Michigan Medicine, answers what fluoride is and why it supports healthy teeth.
Department News
$5.7 M Grant to Study Immune Responses and Healthy Viruses in Pregnancy
Researchers to explore how pregnancy-related immune system changes are influenced by normal viruses that infect human cells.
koniba assandra
Department News
Dr. Kobi Essandoh receives the Benedict R. Lucchesi Young Scientist Travel Award in Cardiac Pharmacology
Dr. Kobi Essandoh receives the Benedict R. Lucchesi Young Scientist Travel Award in Cardiac Pharmacology
girl brushing teeth with family in bathroom looking in mirror drawing
Health Lab
Over 1/3 of parents say their child has experienced dental problems that reflect oral hygiene habits
More than one in three parents say their child has faced issues like tooth decay, cavities, stained teeth, gum concerns or tooth pain over the past two years linked to their oral health routine, a national poll suggests.
drawing of three hands with pills in hand background green
Health Lab
Adderall shortage may be associated with increased use of alternative ADHD medication in kids
Study suggests that the Adderall shortage did not cause many children to stop stimulant therapy altogether but may have led to them switching to alternative stimulants for ADHD.